WhyToBuyThis
Making Your Case: The Art of Persuading Judges (Scalia & Garner)
For Him / Her / Kids

Making Your Casepersuasion advice from the bench itself

Making Your Case: The Art of Persuading Judges (Scalia & Garner)

Reviewed by the WhyToBuyThis team · Updated September 2026 · How we choose

Perfect for

  • Litigators
  • Law students
  • Moot court
  • Legal writing
Check it out

Price: $29.95

Price may change on Amazon. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This won't cost you anything extra.

  • Great gift ideaChosen for real-world gifting
  • Hand-pickedCurated, not scraped
  • Honest reviewThe catch, not just the hype

Why this gift works

Making Your Case: The Art of Persuading Judges is by Justice Antonin Scalia and legal-writing expert Bryan A. Garner, published by Thomson/West in 2008. It is organized as 115 short sections in four parts - argumentation, legal reasoning, briefing and oral argument - so it reads as a set of rules a busy litigator can dip into.

Advice on persuasion straight from a Supreme Court justice is rare, which is why the book became a staple for litigators and law students. It is compact, practical and easy to keep on the desk.

Who is this gift for?

Great for

  • A young associate preparing a first oral argument
  • A law student on the moot court team

Think twice if

  • They practice transactional law
  • They already own a copy

The catch

It dates from 2008 and has not been updated, and experienced lawyers may find some of the tips obvious.

Skip for a transactional lawyer who never argues in court, or someone who already owns it.

Key specs

Making Your Case: The Art of Persuading Judges (Scalia & Garner) specifications
AuthorsAntonin Scalia and Bryan A. Garner
PublisherThomson/West
Published2008
FormatHardcover
Structure115 sections in 4 parts: argumentation, reasoning, briefing, oral argument

Worth knowing before you buy

  • It was published in 2008.
  • The title is Making Your Case, not Make Your Case.

Why we like it

  • Practical rules from a Supreme Court justice
  • Short sections that are easy to dip into
  • A litigator staple

What to look for in a legal writing book

  • Practice area. Litigation books suit trial and appellate lawyers; others suit drafting.
  • Format. Short sections are easier to use on a busy schedule.
  • Author. Books by judges and leading advocates carry extra weight.

Questions people ask

Justice Antonin Scalia and Bryan A. Garner.

Featured in these gift guides

More gifts they'll like

More gifts for lawyers

Gift etiquette

Not sure how much to spend?

Get a typical spending range for any relationship and occasion - and see what's actually expected.

Ready to check it out?

See the latest price and full details on Amazon.

Check it out

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This won't cost you anything extra.