How We Test: Our 5-Step Review Process
Transparent, rigorous testing you can trust - no sponsorships, no shortcuts
Our 5 Testing Phases
Our Complete Testing Methodology
Every product goes through our systematic 5-step process to ensure you get the most accurate and trustworthy recommendations possible.
Product Selection
We analyze Amazon bestsellers, user complaints, and emerging trends to identify products worth testing. Reader requests are prioritized via contact@whytobuythis.com.
Selection Criteria
Hands-On Testing
Lab Tests
Benchmark performance with professional tools (e.g., decibel meters for noise tests, thermal cameras for heat analysis)
Real-World Use
30+ day trials under normal conditions to test durability and everyday performance
Comparison
Side-by-side evaluation vs. 3-5 competing products in the same category and price range
20-Point Scoring System
Every product is evaluated using our comprehensive 20-point criteria system with weighted categories for fair comparison.
Verification
We double-check specifications with manufacturers and monitor price fluctuations weekly to ensure our data stays current and accurate.
Data Sources
Final Recommendation
Only the top 20% of products earn our 'Best Pick' badge. Every review includes clear pros/cons lists and honest recommendations.
Best Pick
Top 20% products with outstanding performance
Recommended
Good value products with solid performance
Skip
Products that don't meet our quality standards
Our 20-Point Scoring System
Every product is evaluated across five key categories with specific metrics and weights to ensure fair, consistent, and comprehensive reviews.
How We Score
Rating Scale
Example: How We Scored a Bluetooth Speaker
What Makes Our Testing Trustworthy
Our commitment to transparency and independence sets us apart from other review sites. Here's what you can count on from every WhyToBuyThis review.
🔍 100+ Hours Per Review
Each product undergoes extensive testing over multiple weeks. We don't rush - thorough evaluation takes time to uncover real-world performance issues.
📊 Data-Driven Ratings
Our scores come from measurable metrics, not gut feelings. We use professional tools and standardized tests to ensure consistent, objective evaluations.
🤝 No Brand Partnerships
We buy every product ourselves and accept zero sponsorship deals. Our only income comes from Amazon affiliate commissions - which never influence our ratings.
Additional Quality Assurance
Multiple Reviewers
Every product tested by 2-3 team members for diverse perspectives
Photo Documentation
Every claim backed by original photos and test results
Regular Updates
Reviews updated when prices change or new models release
Reader Feedback
We monitor and respond to reader experiences and concerns
Our Testing Ethics
We're committed to providing honest, unbiased reviews that help you make informed purchasing decisions. Every product is tested under the same rigorous conditions, and we never let affiliate relationships influence our recommendations.
Our Testers in Action
Meet the team behind every review. Our experienced testers bring diverse backgrounds in engineering, consumer electronics, and product design to ensure comprehensive evaluations.
Lab Testing
Our engineers use professional measuring equipment to benchmark performance metrics like battery life, signal strength, and build quality.
Real-World Usage
Every product is tested in realistic conditions over 30+ days to understand long-term performance and everyday usability.
Documentation
Professional photography and detailed notes ensure every finding is properly documented and can be verified by our readers.
Our Testing Team
Technical Expertise
Consumer Focus
See This Methodology In Action
Experience our rigorous testing process firsthand. Check out our most detailed review to see exactly how we evaluate products from unboxing to final recommendation.
View Our Latest ReviewsRequest a Product Review
Have a specific product you'd like us to test? Send us your suggestions and we'll prioritize reader requests in our testing queue.
Send RequestQuestions About Our Process?
Want to know more about how we test specific product categories? Our team is happy to explain our methodology in detail.
Contact UsOur methodology is constantly evolving to serve you better. Last updated: December 2024